Love bytes: “Her”
I was more interested in seeing “Her” than I originally thought. Sure, Spike Jonze did the excellent “Being John Malkovich,” and I liked “Adaptation” plenty, too. But really … what kind of sick, twisted person casts Scarlett Johansson in a movie for only her voice?
Actually, “Her” has a few things going for it. In addition to Spike and
Scarlett, you have Public Kook No. 1, Joaquin Phoenix, playing another semi-outcast
with issues – in this case a lonely fella named Theo whose job is writing
heartfelt letters for other people. He’s good at that but not so much with
real-life ladies, hanging mostly with a platonic pal played by a dowdy Amy
Adams. (A side-by-side of her look here with the one in “American Hustle” would
be fascinating.)
Did I mention this takes place in the near future, when a mustachioed
Phoenix has the option of buying a new super-intuitive talking operating
system? That’s where Lady Scarlett comes in as the sultry-voiced Samantha. Oh,
she’s no vixen to start, simply a female who really “gets” our hero. It’s
uncanny and unsettling to start, but before long Joaquin is into it. And who wouldn’t
be? Between going through a divorce and failing to connect with blind dates and
anonymous phone sex partners alike, a guy can be excused for thinking the face
and body – or even having a face and
body – just might not matter when a woman truly invades your brain.
Of course, if only things stopped there. Alas, the mental connection
becomes emotional, fed not only by Theo’s melancholy but Samantha’s curiosity
about what it’s like to be human. Her evolution in conjunction with that of
their relationship soon begs a few questions of where this will go, and “Her”
does a nice job of adapting the usual peaks and valleys of a relationship to
this new XY-OS dynamic.
Any who has been paying attention knows Phoenix is the real deal as an
actor. I won’t pretend he killed it in “SpaceCamp” – and really, who could
compete with jumpsuited Lea Thompson – but he was starting to bring it as early
as “8MM” and “Gladiator” more than a dozen years ago. Then came “Walk the Line”
and “The Master,” two different roles but ones I thought he inhabited fully.
Theo in “Her” is more subdued but no less agonized, and Phoenix handles it just
about perfectly.
And he didn’t have to use
only his voice! Johansson’s curves are sorely missed, but I found myself
hanging on every word that came through Theo’s earpiece. Sure, Samantha sounds
just like a normal woman, but Jonze’ script does a good job of regularly and subtly
reminding you she’s not. It’s harmless at first, but eventually Samantha shows
her fair share of confusion and pain as well.
The rest of the cast is solid. Along with Adams, there’s Chris Pratt as
the goofy secretary at Theo’s office and Rooney Mara as Theo’s soon-to-be
ex-wife; after glimpsing her in flashbacks, watching her lunch with Theo becomes
rather painful in short order. Olivia Wilde is always a treat – this time as
the blind date – and see if you can catch a bit part by Kristen Wiig.
In the end, though, this is a love story about two “people,” and Jonze
impressively follows the arc of their relationship to a conclusion that is not
unexpected but still layered and inventive. Not only was I pleased, but I
appreciated the way this relationship made me think. If only my Commodore 64
had understood the preteen me as well. Life could have been so different.